Sign in

You're signed outSign in or to get full access.

MC

MUNCY COLUMBIA FINANCIAL Corp (CCFN)·Q4 2024 Earnings Summary

Executive Summary

  • Q4 2024 delivered solid profitability with net income of $5.224M and EPS of $1.47, up sequentially from $1.42 and a sharp YoY swing from a Q4 2023 loss due to prior merger-related costs .
  • Balance sheet mix continued to improve: deposits rose $1.96M in the quarter as management migrated customer repurchase agreements into core deposits; short-term borrowings fell $4.637M and long-term borrowings fell $4.929M, supporting liquidity optimization .
  • Asset quality tightened: non-performing assets increased to $10.117M (0.63% of assets) from $8.575M (0.53%) in Q3, driven by higher non-accrual residential real estate loans; monitoring credit trends is a near-term focus .
  • Capital and margin improved: equity-to-assets was 10.43% and YTD fully tax-equivalent net interest margin reached 3.46% (vs. 3.40% in Q3 and 2.34% in 2023), aided by earning asset yields and funding mix .
  • Wall Street consensus estimates were unavailable via S&P Global during retrieval; beat/miss vs estimates cannot be assessed at this time (S&P Global request limit) [GetEstimates error].

What Went Well and What Went Wrong

What Went Well

  • EPS rose to $1.47 and net income to $5.224M, continuing sequential improvement and reversing last year’s merger-driven loss .
  • Funding mix improved as deposits increased and both short-term and long-term borrowings declined, consistent with the strategic migration of repurchase agreements to core deposits, which management says will continue into 2025 .
  • Capital and margin strengthened: equity-to-assets hit 10.43% at year-end; YTD FTE NIM reached 3.46%, up from 3.40% in Q3 and 2.34% in 2023, signaling sustained spread improvement .
  • Quote: “The Bank anticipates a continued migration of customer repurchase accounts from short-term borrowings to deposits moving into 2025.” .

What Went Wrong

  • Asset quality pressure: non-performing assets rose to $10.117M (0.63% of assets) from $8.575M (0.53%) in Q3, driven by higher non-accrual loans including a $1.285M increase in non-accrual residential real estate .
  • Net interest expense remained elevated vs pre-merger comparisons, reflecting industry rate dynamics (deposits interest expense $6.049M in Q4), though funding mix is improving .
  • Slight book value per share decline sequentially ($47.11 vs. $47.35 in Q3), though up YoY; accumulated other comprehensive loss remains a headwind to equity (AOCI -$13.896M at Dec 31, 2024) .

Financial Results

MetricQ4 2023Q2 2024Q3 2024Q4 2024
Total net revenue ($USD Millions)$10.52 $14.78 $15.49 $16.11
Net interest income ($USD Millions)$8.26 $12.36 $12.77 $13.40
Non-interest income ($USD Millions)$2.27 $2.42 $2.72 $2.71
EPS ($USD)($0.41) $1.32 $1.42 $1.47
Net income ($USD Millions)$(1.19) $4.71 $5.06 $5.22
ROAA (%)-0.35% 1.20% 1.26% 1.30%
ROAE (%)-3.95% 12.28% 12.34% 12.30%
FTE NIM (YTD, %)2.34% 3.36% 3.40% 3.46%

Notes: “Total net revenue” is derived as Net interest income + Non-interest income using reported figures in the Consolidated Statements of Income .

Segment breakdown: Not applicable; results are reported on a consolidated basis.

KPIs

KPIQ2 2024Q3 2024Q4 2024
Total assets ($USD Millions)$1,592.3 $1,607.3 $1,596.0
Loans, net + HFS ($USD Millions)$1,092.1 $1,105.4 $1,117.8
Total deposits ($USD Millions)$1,265.6 $1,290.5 $1,292.4
Short-term borrowings ($USD Millions)$89.3 $73.0 $68.4
Long-term borrowings ($USD Millions)$65.6 $60.5 $55.5
Core deposits ($USD Millions)$926.8 $938.9 $943.7
NPA ($USD Millions)$7.736 $8.575 $10.117
NPA / Assets (%)0.49% 0.53% 0.63%
ACL to total loans (%)0.85% 0.85% 0.88%
Equity-to-assets (%)9.90% 10.53% 10.43%
Book value per share ($)$44.11 $47.35 $47.11
Dividend declared per share ($)$0.44 $0.44 $0.44

Guidance Changes

MetricPeriodPrevious GuidanceCurrent GuidanceChange
Deposit mix migration (repurchase to core deposits)2024→2025Initiative underway in Q2–Q3 2024 “Continued migration … moving into 2025” Maintained/extended
Dividend (quarterly)Q4 2024$0.44 in Q2–Q3 2024 $0.44 in Q4 2024 Maintained

Note: No explicit revenue, margin, OpEx, OI&E, or tax-rate guidance ranges were provided in Q4 materials .

Earnings Call Themes & Trends

Transcript unavailable in our document set for Q4 2024; themes reflect management’s press releases.

TopicQ2 2024 (Prev-2)Q3 2024 (Prev-1)Q4 2024 (Current)Trend
Deposit migration to core accountsInitiative launched; deposits +$52.1M; ST borrowings -$36.6M Continued; deposits +$24.8M; ST borrowings -$16.3M Continues into 2025; deposits +$1.96M; ST borrowings -$4.6M Positive mix shift
Net interest marginYTD FTE NIM 3.36% YTD FTE NIM 3.40% YTD FTE NIM 3.46% Improving
Asset quality (NPA)NPA $7.736M (0.49%) NPA $8.575M (0.53%) NPA $10.117M (0.63%); non-accrual residential +$1.285M Worsening
CapitalEquity/assets 9.90%; BVPS $44.11 Equity/assets 10.53%; BVPS $47.35 Equity/assets 10.43%; BVPS $47.11 Strong, stable
AOCI on securitiesUnrealized losses reduce equity by $16.936M Unrealized losses reduce equity by $8.809M Unrealized losses reduce equity by $13.896M (YoY improvement vs $15.036M) Variable with rates

Management Commentary

  • “The Bank anticipates a continued migration of customer repurchase accounts from short-term borrowings to deposits moving into 2025. The execution of this initiative will assist in optimizing the Bank’s long-term liquidity needs and balance sheet management strategies.” .
  • Management reiterated that changes in market interest rates, mortgage prepayment speeds, and bid-ask spreads drive valuation swings in agency MBS/agency debt and flow through AOCI; debt securities are not considered credit impaired (intent/ability to hold to recovery) .
  • Q4 2023 results were “significantly impacted by merger related expenses” tied to the November 2023 transaction, contextualizing YoY improvement in Q4 2024 .

Q&A Highlights

  • No Q4 2024 earnings call transcript found in our document set; Q&A highlights unavailable.

Estimates Context

  • S&P Global consensus estimates for Q4 2024 EPS and revenue were unavailable at time of retrieval (SPGI daily request limit exceeded), so beat/miss vs Street cannot be determined now [GetEstimates error].
  • Near-term estimate revisions may reflect: stronger sequential EPS, higher net interest income, and elevated NPA levels that could temper credit cost assumptions .

Key Takeaways for Investors

  • Earnings momentum: Sequential EPS improvement to $1.47, with total net revenue up to ~$16.1M; supports short-term constructive sentiment absent Street consensus context .
  • Funding mix: Ongoing migration from repurchase agreements to core deposits is lowering reliance on wholesale funding and could support margin durability into 2025 .
  • Margin trajectory: YTD FTE NIM increased to 3.46%, signaling improving core profitability as repricing benefits and mix changes flow through .
  • Credit watch: NPA rose to 0.63% of assets and non-accrual residential real estate increased by $1.285M; monitor credit costs and any spillover into provisions .
  • Capital cushion: Equity-to-assets at 10.43% and BVPS at $47.11 provide balance sheet resilience; dividend maintained at $0.44 in Q4 .
  • AOCI sensitivity: Unrealized losses in the securities portfolio continue to affect equity (AOCI -$13.896M), tied to rate and market dynamics; rate normalization could improve AOCI over time .
  • Tactical lens: Near-term catalysts include continued deposit migration progress and any updates on credit trends; negative surprises would likely center on asset quality deterioration or margin compression.